Judge not and ye shall not be judged, or something like that. I can understand how your views have changed now that you have retired as a solicitor. Still, often one can say that behaviour is wrong, but many people and organisations are too inclined to make excuses for it, whether it is their own behaviour or that of others. It may help if bad behaviour can be explained, but making excuses can mean that it is being condoned. Sorry if I am sounding Biblical.
Indeed it takes all kinds to make the world turn – the good, the bad, the ugly and the beautiful. There is a duality to nature – a duality which humans are intrinsically part of, and which is constantly at odds with itself. When it comes to human behaviour, though, a line has to be drawn at some point. For example, if it causes harm, whether to oneself, others, the environment, etc. And ‘harm’ cannot really be determined by the subject, but rather by the object.
Where there is judgement, there is also room for misjudgement, and as French-American author Anaïs Nin wrote, ‘We don’t see things as they are, we see them as we are.”.
Another thoughtful episode. Well done.
A very good piece Ant. Like you, I suspect I have become more accommodating with age. But as you say, there’s always the case “where somebody does something really bad.” What did Hegel make of that? Perhaps that some rights are less wrong than others?
Yes, Hegel saw many rights as absolute, defined through the ultimate ‘synthesis’ of the dialectic. I suppose my parallel here, beyond just a good turn of phrase for the podcast at least (!), is that there will be a lot of ‘theses’ and ‘antitheses’ along the way! Marx of course developed the dialectic principle of Hegel to a very different outcome of rights.
Judge not and ye shall not be judged, or something like that. I can understand how your views have changed now that you have retired as a solicitor. Still, often one can say that behaviour is wrong, but many people and organisations are too inclined to make excuses for it, whether it is their own behaviour or that of others. It may help if bad behaviour can be explained, but making excuses can mean that it is being condoned. Sorry if I am sounding Biblical.
Indeed it takes all kinds to make the world turn – the good, the bad, the ugly and the beautiful. There is a duality to nature – a duality which humans are intrinsically part of, and which is constantly at odds with itself. When it comes to human behaviour, though, a line has to be drawn at some point. For example, if it causes harm, whether to oneself, others, the environment, etc. And ‘harm’ cannot really be determined by the subject, but rather by the object.
Where there is judgement, there is also room for misjudgement, and as French-American author Anaïs Nin wrote, ‘We don’t see things as they are, we see them as we are.”.
Another thoughtful episode. Well done.
A very good piece Ant. Like you, I suspect I have become more accommodating with age. But as you say, there’s always the case “where somebody does something really bad.” What did Hegel make of that? Perhaps that some rights are less wrong than others?
Author
Yes, Hegel saw many rights as absolute, defined through the ultimate ‘synthesis’ of the dialectic. I suppose my parallel here, beyond just a good turn of phrase for the podcast at least (!), is that there will be a lot of ‘theses’ and ‘antitheses’ along the way! Marx of course developed the dialectic principle of Hegel to a very different outcome of rights.